Title →

Top 10 Car Insurance Companies for Young Drivers in the USA

Share On →

Car Insurance Companies.

Are you a young driver looking for the best car insurance companies? Well, you are in the right place! I understand that as a young driver, it is important to secure your car insurance for both financial security and peace of mind during times of uncertainty.

However, in this blog, I have listed the top insurance companies in the USA for young enthusiasts like you! So let’s quickly get started and help you make a knowledgeable decision about a good choice for your car.

List of the Top Car Insurance Companies

  1. Erie
  2. USAA
  3. American Family
  4. Nationwide
  5. Auto-Owners
  6. Geico
  7. State Farm
  8. Allstate
  9. Amica
  10. Encompass

1. Erie

  • CEO: Timothy G. NeCastro
  • Headquarters: Erie, Pennsylvania
  • Year Of Establishment:1925

Erie offers many types of insurance coverage including those especially beneficial for teens and young drivers.

New Car Replacement Coverage: If a driver’s car is damaged within the first two years or 24,000 miles, the company will replace it with a brand-new car of the same model.

Gap Insurance: In this coverage, the company helps fill the gap between the actual cash value of the destroyed car and the pending loan or lease balance.

Rideshare Insurance: When young drivers participate in ridesharing services like Uber or Lyft, the company provides coverage of any mishappening caused during the rideshare activities.

Lock-in Rate: Erie allows policyholders to lock in their rates until they make changes in their policy. For example, during the lock-in period, if you purchase a car or add one to your policy, your rates will remain unchanged.

The additional perks of this company are that they give extra bonuses in the areas where other companies might charge an extra amount. For example, glass repair with no deductible, locksmith service up to $75, personal items coverage up to $350, and basic rental car insurance.

Erie focuses not only on customer satisfaction and complete coverage options but also on giving competitive rates that make it useful for teens and young drivers. Well, all these make Erie one of the best and top car insurance companies for young drivers of today.



  • CEO: Wayne Peacock
  • Headquarters: San Antonio, Texas
  • Year Of Establishment:1922

USAA offers several services that are especially beneficial for teens and young drivers.

Affordable Rates: The company provides some of the lowest rates compared to many car insurance companies. Therefore, affordability is of great advantage to the teens and the young drivers.

Excellent Customer Service: USAA is highly ranked for its customer service, claims handling, and discounts. Their commitment to serving their clients the best is a perk to the young drivers.

Discounts: The company provides unique discounts for student drivers with good grades, safe driving, and bundled policies.

Rideshare Coverage: USAA also provides coverage up to $1,000,000 for rideshare activities.

The company exclusively serves military members, veterans, and their families. Their understanding of the military needs and their unique lifestyle make them different from others. Because of the high customer satisfaction, policyholders are more likely to recommend them to others.

3. American Family

  • CEO: Bill Westrate
  • Headquarters: Madison, Wisconsin, United States
  • Year Of Establishment: 1927

American Family offers car insurance services to teens and young drivers.

Good Student Discount: The American Family often gives discounts to students with good grades. If you are a young driver still in school this can be of great help to you.

Driver Training Programs: The company may also offer training programs and driving courses for young driving enthusiasts. Completing these courses can lead to discounts on your insurance.

Safe Driving Rewards: Some policies include rewards for safe driving behavior. This is to encourage avoiding accidents and traffic violations, with this you may qualify for additional discounts.

What makes the American Family stand out is its wide range of discounts, which can help reduce costs for policyholders. Additionally, the company ranks third in handling claims and fifth in customer service among car insurance companies.

4. Nationwide


  • CEO: Kirt Walker
  • Headquarters: Columbus, Ohio, United States
  • Year Of Establishment: 1926

Nationwide offers several services that are especially beneficial for teens and young drivers.

Collision Coverage: This helps you pay for the damage caused to your vehicle when it hit another vehicle, or if the vehicle rolls over as a young driver driving it.

Liability Coverage: This covers damages if you are found at fault in an accident. Minimum liability coverage is very important by the law to keep teens and other drivers safe.

Comprehensive Coverage: This helps in the case of you being involved in an accident that does not involve any other vehicle. Things such as theft, trashing, or certain weather-related damages.

Rental Car Reimbursement: Here it covers the cost of a rental car or other transportation such as bus or subway. This helps in case your car cannot be driven due to an at-fault accident as a young driver.

The company also gives good student discounts. But, what makes Nationwide stand out is its competitive rates for various driver profiles like parents, senior citizens, teens, and those with poor credits. This company has a very low number of complaints to state insurance departments than average.

5. Auto-Owners

  • CEO: Jeffrey S Tagsold
  • Headquarters: Lansing, Michigan, United States
  • Year Of Establishment: 1916

Let’s learn about what services Auto-Owners offer especially beneficial for teens and young drivers.

Affordability: Auto-Owners is known for its affordable bonuses. The cost for teenagers added to a parent’s policy,  is typically lower than what other companies charge for an adult and teen. For example, adding an 18-year-old to an adult’s policy costs only $42 per month, making it an attractive option for families.

Coverage Options: Auto owners likely provide standard car insurance coverage. This includes crash coverage, liability coverage, and complete coverage.

Quality Ratings: Auto-Owners has received a great grade from crash repair professionals, indicating its dedication to quality service.

Cheapest Car Insurance for Teens: Auto-Owners ranks as the cheapest car insurance company for teenagers on a parent’s policy, costing around $153 per month for an 18-year-old and a 50-year-old.

Its strong reliability and financial stability make it very essential and helpful for teens and young drivers. Additionally, its affordability makes it a great choice for families.



  • CEO: Todd Combs
  • Headquarters: Maryland, United States
  • Year Of Establishment: 1936

GEICO offers several services that are especially beneficial for teens and young drivers.

DriveEasy Program: DriveEasy is a program that offers discounts through the GEICO mobile app on your car insurance by observing safe driving habits. It’s like safe driving with a discount.

GEICO Discounts: Additional discounts for teen drivers include good student discounts where teenage drivers can get up to 15% off on certain coverages. A good driver discount where the driver has not been in an accident within the last 5 years will earn 22% on most coverage.

Reduce Teen Active Distracted Driving: Data shows that teens spend 55% more time simultaneously handling their phones while driving. Therefore, this is a unique initiative to avoid accidents caused by distractions.

GEICO stands out due to its affordable insurance rates. And its variety of discounts make it one of the most liked and one of the best car insurance companies for young drivers.

7. State Farm

  • CEO: Michael L. Tipsord
  • Headquarters: Bloomington, Illinois, United States
  • Year Of Establishment: 1922

State Farm offers many types of insurance coverage including those especially beneficial for teens and young drivers.

Good Student Discount: Teens who pursue good grades can save up to 25% on their car insurance till the age of 25. But what about the home school? Well, even they can save up to 20% based on their ranks over the past 12 months.

Driver Training Discount: If one of the drivers of the vehicle is recognized to be a student aged around 25 moves away from home to school, and is only using the car while at home during school holidays and vacations, they may be permitted to enjoy this discount.

Discounts Based on Safe Driving Habits: State Farm presents programs like ‘Steer Clear’ and ‘Drive Safe & Save’ to support lower car insurance costs while teaching young drivers safer driving habits.

The company is also working on other options to reduce the prices of its insurance like considering purchasing a safer car for a teen. And, reducing or removing complete coverage if the teen’s car has a low value.

8. Allstate

  • CEO: Thomas J. Wilson
  • Headquarters: Northbrook, Illinois, U.S.
  • Year Of Establishment: 1931

Allstate offers many types of insurance coverage including those especially beneficial for teens and young drivers.

Auto insurance for teens: Here the company is doing many things like rewarding safe drivers, and introducing technology for safe driving with tools like Drivewise to provide personalized insights. Additionally, accident forgiveness, and rental refunds where Allstate helps cover the cost of a rental car. Roadside assistance with apps like Allstate provides quick access to services like towing, tire changes, and jump starts. It’s like having a safety shield on the road.

Graduated driver licensing (GDL): Familiarize yourself with your state’s GDL laws. These laws, such as learner’s permits, help lower driving risks for young drivers and ensure you learn safely.

Guidance wherever they go: While an elder can’t always be with you, their guidance can go wherever you go. Allstate’s services and programs help you drive safely on the road.

Allstate offers a variety of car insurance coverage options making it one of the best car insurance companies in 2024 for young drivers like you.

9. Amica

  • CEO: Edmund (Ted) Shallcross III
  • Headquarters: Lincoln, Rhode Island, United States
  • Year Of Establishment: 1907

Amica offers many types of insurance coverage including those especially beneficial for teens and young drivers.

Good student discounts: Amica offers a good student discount for full-time students who maintain at least a B average (3.0 GPA).

Driver training programs: Like many other companies, Amica provides discounts for drivers under the age of 21 who complete a recognized driver training program.

Safe driving habits: As you gain experience and display good driving behavior, your insurance company may charge you less by the time you turn 19 years old.

This way Amica helps young drivers and encourages them to be safe on the roads.

10. Encompass

  • CEO: Carlos A. Romero
  • Headquarters: Northbrook, Illinois, United States
  • Year Of Establishment: 1999

Encompass offers many types of insurance coverage including those especially beneficial for teens and young drivers.

Roadside assistance: Encompass provides 24/7 roadside assistance through its free mobile app. Whether you face a flat tire, run out of gas, or need a jump-start, you will always have help at your fingertips.

Accident fact kit: Encourage you to keep an Accident Fact Kit in your car. This kit provides a list of steps to take immediately after a crash.

Catastrophe claims guide: In case of a tragedy, Encompass has a dedicated National Catastrophe Team. This guide outlines what to expect during the claims process, providing a smoother recovery.

Therefore the company aims to keep you safe always!

End Note

As we conclude our journey through the top car insurance companies, we realize that choosing the right insurance company for your car as a young driver doesn’t have to be difficult! I hope this list helps you find the best one for your needs.

Remember choosing the right company makes all the difference in how prepared or devastated you will be during an uncertainty. So, take your next step today and secure your peace of mind on the road. Ensure your car’s safety and drive safely with all your confidence!

Simran Khan